Winterwind-NS's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[The End (Super Mario RPG)]

wow!

people don't usually remake this song from mario, and thank you for submitting this to the Video Game section and not the classical section, that annoys me when people do that lol.
This was beautifully done.
4:45 where the pizzicato playing begins is great and those scherzo cues from the flutes and trumpets sounded nice.
haahhahah and the ending just made me laff

awesome job dude

-Winter

[String Trio no. 1]

the infamous dee miner

I already told you how I feel
bi lol

-Winter

MusicalRocky responds:

the infamous winter minor

I already told u how I feel about u and ur opinion.

cya lawl

-Rocks

[Pt. 1 - The Vision (Revised)]

bravo

my favorite part that stood out the most to me I'd say was at 3:00
picking up the pace the way it did was very nice.
appropriate use of every instrument, although sometimes I kinda felt a few percussion parts seemed a bit random.
I also liked what sounded to me a screaming trumpet holding a note at 4:00?
You, sir, make film music very interesting and intensely diverse.
the ending was beautiful
like awaking from a dream, or entering one, fits either perfectly fine.

I am looking forward to more songs by you my friend
I love what you do

-Winter

[classical piano#2]

Wow egoraptor chose the wrong song to review

I don't think it's very fair to refer to this song as your music as seen in the first review's response.
It'd be swell if you could properly credit the original composer and the full title of the piece as well.
Frederic Chopin - Nocturne no. 1 in G minor op. 37
Also, you did not perform this, this is stolen, I have this same recording in a romantic piano compilation CD called Music Classica I believe.
I looked it up on limewire and found the same recording from my CD and this one that you uploaded except it cuts off at 5:04 like this one even though the piece has much more to it.
way to go.
I'll be waiting for your response

[The Vision]

Hey man

I'm glad you reviewed my song
otherwise I wouldn't have heard your music sooner
fantastic song you got there and great equipment as well to equal your abilities.
most people here tend to weigh more on one side more than the other if you get what I mean.
Not much more to say other than what Simon has already pointed out. He has that effect on my reviews too often lol
Great job man
You're in my fav's liszt

-Winter

[Happy Birthday March]

OMG DUDE

THANK YOU SOOOOOOO MUCH!!!
that was incredibly thoughtful
including the Cminor segment
which was totally a musthave
this was really well done as well haha
LOL this was totally unexpected thanks so much again dude

I really appreciate this

-Winter

MusicalRocky responds:

hahahha
no problems
I had the idea on Thursday. I even told u I had a great idea, and that it dealt with your bday lol. You should've known.
yeah cm was a must. CAUSE BIRTHDAYS CAN BE EVIL. (aka Heath :[)

Anyway I'm glad you liked it haha. It better've been unexpected.

UR WELCOME,

Rocky

[Violin Duet in Dm]

OMG I RECOGNIZE IT

hahaha I'm glad I recognized it
and the part leading up to it was awesome
when I heard it I was like YES thats such a win
but I wont burst ur bubble and tell everyone else lolol
but awesome dude that was great how u put it in there
it fit perfectly as if this was where it originated

oh and of course the rest of the piece was great as well
hahaahahahha i just heard the ending
NICEE dude i thought u would do something like that with such a ownage theme.
it was nearing the end and it still wasnt really resolving but then i heard that melody n i was like o thank god lol

aight enuff blabbering
awesome dude
hire ppl to play this cuz i know ur lame ass cant lolol

this was a LOT better than i thought it would turn out

-Winter

MusicalRocky responds:

yay u recognized it lol. yeah I enjoyed that "conversation" that occurred before the revelation of the theme haha. You like how the two alternate the theme? lol

haha yeah the rest of the piece. I hope it's good, it's kinda what I wrote. lol
lol of course I came back to teh theme at the end.

haha blabbering. yeah I need to hire like sarah chang and someone else...hilary hahn lol. word.

glad u like it dude.

-Rocks

[La Batalla Dentro del Castillo]

as awesome as afuera del castillo

I like this one as much as the other batalla
the ritard at 0:33 i thought was very effective
after the entire intro, the ritard made it seem like something big just entered instead of like, a ritard to the end of a piece.
That other reviewer below me phrased his thoughts in what I felt was the rudest way possible without appearing like a complete douchebag
This piece conjures up plenty of visuals, half of which he listed as examples i felt in this song.
Dont take offense to his review
how surprising it is that he's my age

anyways
awesome song, shitty first review

-Winter

MusicalRocky responds:

lawls well I guess it gains value with each listen cause the first time u were like "not as good as the first one tho." haha

yeah I get that feeling with the ritard too. WE ARE PSYKICK LOL AND THINK THE SAME THINGS. haha

yeah that was a gay review below. it would've been enough to say "I didn't really get any emotion from this piece, but I'm sure others will!" or something. idk.

don't worry about it lol. ur review is awethumb

thanks man,

Rocky

[Kriz: The Beginning]

Not bad

Not very hardcore and somewhat mellow
I liked the hat that's delayed into quarter triplets
its different
the break was really nice
only thing that really bothered me was at 1:45
that synth was a bit too loud compared to the rest
it really surprised me but the melody it plays was really nice
i dont remmeber if it was u i mentioned in a review but I dont like songs that fade out even if it isn't just a simple volume control but yeah
nice song man
NG needs more tracks like this haha

take care

-Winter

Kr1z responds:

Idd, that synth is a lil loudy! i think ill adjust it a lil :)
Yeh u mentioned u dont like fading ends..
But this one is a combination of fade & abrupt, ahwell
im working on it ^^
Thx for the tips!

Kriz!

[´Kriz: Reaching For You]

beautiful

this is a great start
Love the very soft airy pads in the beginning
they give the song so much depth.
The only things that bothered me was the lack of intro and I've never been a fan of fade out endings, even though in this case it wasn't just a volume control thing.
also I would've liked some cool hihat sequences.
Great change from the high plucky synth to that low lead
That second of breath at 1:22 was just perfect I loved that part especially
again great job on a well produced song.

-Winter

Kr1z responds:

Thx for the tips ^^
Cya around!